The first time I saw Neapolitan pizza was during my senior year in high school. As an editor of the school paper that received less funding than the chess club, we held a monthly after school pizza sale in attempts to print a few pages in colored ink. For a reason that escapes me now, one of my peers ordered our usual amount of pies from a different pizzeria than usual, probably because they gave us free delivery. But the free delivery was not worth the monetary loses we suffered that day. I will never forget the looks of disgust the typical American high school students at Scotch Plains-Fanwood High School gave our pizza. “Why is the cheese in little blobs and not all over like regular pizza?” asked a freshman. “What did you order this pizza from Hung’s Chinese place?” mocked another student. That day was the first time we lost money on our fundraiser, and as I drove home with the extras in hand I cursed Sorrento’s pizzeria and their so called legitimate Italian pizza. Upon reheating in the oven and biting into a large droopy slice, my tune was changed forever. How misguided my peers were in their petty judgments of cheese blobs! This was how pizza is supposed to taste! Fresh and like real food! Let the heathens feast on their Elio’s and Pizza Hut, for I had been converted in my darkest hour from an atheist, to an unadulterated pizza traditionalist.
The years before my time in Italy were uneventful in terms of my pizza journey, with less than edible creations at college in Washington, D.C. and satisfactory samples at home in New Jersey. And while I didn’t base my decision to live and study in Italy for a few months on pizza alone, the fact that the country birthed my sustenance soul mate did influence my subconscious. I took Roma by storm and in my first week alone devoured more pizza than the yearly recommended allowance by the FDA. I knew that my body was going to hate me for the mass quantities of bread, tomato sauce, and cheese I was consuming, but I had to find the right place to win title of “Best Pizza in the Whole Wide World”.
An e-mail from my eldest cousin, who had recently married into a “more authentic” Italian family than mine, sent me researching a restaurant in southern city of Naples, which her husband recommended and that she had read about in a popular novel. Antica Pizzeria da Michele boasted that they had baked the perfect pie since 1870 on their cheesy website complete with “That’s Amore” playing in the background. Always skeptical, especially of recommendations, I read countless reviews most which claimed the most delicious pizza in the world. It didn’t take much to coax two friends to join me on the quick train trip down to Italy’s third biggest city to decide for ourselves if “da Michele” could hold the championship title.
Referencing a few different guidebooks had us a little scared about the people of Naples and their 30% unemployment rate. Prepared to walk into a crack den, we were pleasantly surprised when no one ambushed us and ransacked our bags. After wandering around for a few hours we made our way back towards the train station and down Via Pietro Colletta. It wasn’t difficult to find our first destination with a decent crowd congregating outside. Taking a number and waiting among many in anticipation, the three of us were seated pretty quickly at a table for four in a crowded dining room. We were given no menus for our marble table top, but found a lone page taped to the wall with only 3 options: marinara, mozzarella, or dopia mozzarella. Double mozzarella seemed like the natural choice and mere minutes later pizza’s spilling over their plates were set down in front of us. The crust was airy and light, while the center was molten lava of sauce and cheese. We eagerly sliced into the gooey mess and began to devour the heavenly creation. Each bite was constant, a juicy swirl of flavors on my palate. There was nothing complex about the taste, but the simple natural ingredients of wheat dough, San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella, oil, basil, oregano, and garlic melted into a divine delicacy I never wanted to end.
Midway through our pizza, a rotund man with more hair on his chest than his head, was seated as our fourth lunch companion. He mocked our inept technique of cutting small squares and eating with our forks stating, “You let cheese get cold.”
“But it’s so thin! How else can you eat it?” my exasperated friend Tessie asked as his plate was delivered.
But rather than tell us, our new friend simply sliced a large triangle and used his hands and knife simultaneously. His lunch was gone in under 3 minutes, and he bade us goodbye while we were still attempting to swallow our last bites.
“I can’t finish!” exclaimed Kyra. “I am literally going to explode.”
“Me too,” Tessie said. “But when they brought out his hot pizza, my mouth actually starting watering again.”
As my fork and knife clattered to my empty plate and my jeans cut uncomfortably into my stomach, a content smile spread across my face. “That was the best thing I have ever eaten in my whole life,” I said. My friends nodded in agreement and stared down at the remains of their meals. I began to wonder if I could move to Naples, set up shop and just continue to eat at Antica Pizzeria da Michele until I was so large they needed to roll me out of the door. And as fabulous of a life that would be I realized that I needed to continue on my quest, searching for the best pizza in the world. For da Michele is current reigning champion, but just how long can they hold onto their title?



